How to Prevent and Manage Aster Yellows

Phytoplasma

Aster yellows is a devastating disease that can affect more than 300 plant species. And that only includes broad-leaved plants! Aster yellows also affects grain crops like wheat and barley.

Without effective management, the disease can rapidly spiral out of control.

Aster yellows is found throughout North America, Europe, and much of the world’s temperate zones.

Unfortunately, it’s not a treatable condition.

Close up of echinacea flowers with flowers damaged due to aster yellows disease.

We link to vendors to help you find relevant products. If you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission.

The best thing to do with an infected plant is to purge it from your garden, so the disease will not spread.

Read on for ways to prevent your plants from becoming infected with this pernicious organism, and manage it if it does occur.

What Is Aster Yellows Disease?

Aster yellows is caused by microscopic organisms called phytoplasmas that are very similar to bacteria.

Your plants would not be threatened by this disease, were it not for the aster leafhopper (Macrosteles quadrilineatus). As its name suggests, this is a lively insect that hops from plant to plant, spreading the disease.

Top down view of a aster leafhopper (Macrosteles quadrilineatus).
Aster leafopper (Macrosteles quadrilineatus). Photo via Whitney Cranshaw, Colorado State University Bugwood.org, via CC BY-SA. Cropped.

The pathogen responsible is found in the sap of infected plants. When the insect feeds, it sucks up this phytoplasma, transmitting it to nearby plants. The leafhopper can cause infection in just 1-3 weeks and transmits aster yellows every time it feeds for the rest of its life.

Once in the plant, the phytoplasma spreads throughout the entire plant from the root to the flowers. It will take a while for you to realize that your plants are infected, since they typically don’t start showing symptoms for 10-40 days after infection.

While the organism that causes aster yellows does not kill its hosts (unless they are young), it disfigures them so badly that you will no longer want the plants in your garden. If you grow susceptible vegetables, your crop will be damaged.

Plants That Can Become Infected

Common flowering ornamental plants that can become infected include:

Vegetables that are susceptible include:

A large variety of weeds, including plantain, dandelion, thistles, and ragweed can serve as reservoirs of aster yellows.

Symptoms of Aster Yellows

This disease gets its name from asters, since they are one type of plant on which aster yellows shows strong distinctive symptoms. The daisy-like flowers can be transformed into grotesque structures.

For example, aster, daisy, coneflower, and chrysanthemum flowers can have tufts of deformed leaves in them or in place of them. Another common symptom is leaves that turn yellow, while their veins remain green.

Other symptoms include stunting, abnormally bushy growth, new leaves that turn yellow, and twisting or curling of the foliage. In addition, flowers may not produce seed.

Symptoms May Vary

To make things even more difficult, this pathogen produces different symptoms on various types of plants.

Carrot roots can be hairy and bitter, while the inner leaves of lettuce can be twisted, and any of the leaves may show tan or pink spots. The disease is often called “purple top” in potatoes, because the foliage frequently turns purple.

aster yellows on potato
Aster yellows on potato, often called “purple top” due to the purple striation in the leaves. Photo via Alamy.

The symptoms are more noticeable in hot weather, and plants can be infected in cool weather without showing any symptoms. This is particularly unfortunate, since the disease can spread widely in cool and wet summers.

Other factors that can cause variations in symptoms include the age and/or size of the plant when it was infected. Plants that are infected when they are small tend to be stunted and have different leaves that can have rosettes or are narrower than healthy leaves.

Factors That Can Cause Similar Symptoms

Not every plant that looks deformed is infected with aster yellows.

Damage from herbicides can also present these symptoms. This is particularly true when plants have been treated with Weed ‘n’ Feed, a combination fertilizer and herbicide commonly used on lawns to tackle broadleaf weeds.

Witches’-broom, a deformity caused by parasitic plants, can produce similar symptoms.

And coneflowers can be attacked by eriophyid mites that cause tufts of small distorted flower parts that sprout from the cone.

Aster Leafhoppers Love to Travel

The leafhoppers that transmit this disease cannot survive cold winters, like what gardeners experience in Minnesota (although their eggs can survive in the upper Midwest). However, brutally cold winters do not lead to their demise.

A green leafhopper on a stem of grass.
Leafhopper on a grass stem. Photo via Shutterstock.

Within North America, the insects travel to the Gulf of Mexico, where populations build to high levels in grain fields in Missouri and Arkansas.

After overwintering there, they will fly into the upper atmosphere, where storm systems can blow them hundreds of miles north to plague northern gardeners.

In some years, infected leafhoppers arrive early in spring, even before the local insect population has had a chance to become infected. However, given the vagaries of the weather, in other years they are not a problem.

Hot Weather Can Inhibit the Disease

Fortunately for gardeners in hot climates, hot temperatures inactivate the pathogen in both the leafhopper and infected plants. Temperatures of 88°F for 10-12 days are required to limit the growth of the phytoplasma.

How to Manage Aster Yellows

There is no treatment for this disease. The first and most critical thing to do is purge any infected plants from your garden, and destroy all plant matter. This will prevent them from being a source of phytoplasma for the leafhoppers to spread.

Control Weeds

The phytoplasma can survive northern winters in the roots and crowns of infected perennials, including weeds.

Many weeds can harbor this pathogen, so it’s important to remove them from your garden, lawn, and surrounding areas.

You should focus on dandelions and plantain, since they are such common hosts.

Consider Less Susceptible Types of Plants

If aster yellows is a persistent problem in your garden, you can plant alternate types of flowering plants.

Plants that are not susceptible to this disease include:

Control Insects

While purging the leafhoppers from your yard may seem like an excellent solution, this can be difficult to do – unless you are growing susceptible plants on a large scale.

Rows of lettuce plants growing under floating row covers.
Lettuce growing under floating row covers to control leafhoppers and other pests. Photo via Shutterstock.

If you know you are likely to have a problem, you can plant crops like lettuce under floating row covers to keep the insects away.

Another option used by some farmers is to put strips of aluminum foil between the rows. This serves to confuse the leafhoppers, who are then less likely to land on your crops.

Aster Leafhoppers Leave Misshapen Plants in Their Wake

Unless you live in a very hot area, your plants in the aster and composite family are vulnerable to the insidious disease aster yellows.

However, the disease will not spread unless leafhoppers carrying the pathogen are on the loose in your garden. If you know they are a problem, you can take measures to prevent them.

Close up of a green deformed coneflower infected by aster yellows.
A coneflower affected by aster yellows disease. Photo via Alamy.

If you have grotesque misshapen flowers, you will need to quickly remove these plants from your garden to prevent the disease from spreading.

Have you encountered aster yellows in your garden? Were you able to keep it from spreading? Let us know how you fared in the comments.

And read on for more common diseases and pests of garden plants including:

© Ask the Experts, LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. See our TOS for more details.

About Helga George, PhD

One of Helga George’s greatest childhood joys was reading about rare and greenhouse plants that would not grow in Delaware. Now that she lives near Santa Barbara, California, she is delighted that many of these grow right outside! Fascinated by the childhood discovery that plants make chemicals to defend themselves, Helga embarked on further academic study and obtained two degrees, studying plant diseases as a plant pathology major. She holds a BS in agriculture from Cornell University, and an MS from the University of Massachusetts Amherst. Helga then returned to Cornell to obtain a PhD, studying one of the model systems of plant defense. She transitioned to full-time writing in 2009.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
15 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
René
René (@guest_8689)
1 year ago

I have just pulled an echinacea infected with asters yellow. I have never seen it before and am worried about the others planted nearby! Most of the resistant flowers are annuals. As it’s July, I will just have to live with the bare spots in our garden. Very sad.

Pam Snodgrass
Pam Snodgrass (@guest_9565)
1 year ago

My coneflowers developed aster yellows about 3-4 weeks ago. I had never heard of it before, but I noticed the new blooms on my coneflowers were green and misshapen and the leaves turned upward and were dark brown and crunchy. I did a Google search to find out what was happening and immediately after reading about it, I started pulling the coneflowers from my yard. I used a garden fork to lift each plant out of the yard and carefully put them into trash bags, also disposing of all the soil that was attached to the roots. Can you answer… Read more »

Pam Snodgrass
Pam Snodgrass (@guest_9670)
Reply to  Helga George, PhD
1 year ago

Thank you, Helga, for writing back. It has been sad watching plants develop the symptoms and having to pull them out and throw them away. One symptom I’ve noticed that hasn’t been mentioned in any of the reading I’ve done is the leaves curl inward, turn dark brown, and become hard and crunchy. Does that sound like asters yellow to you? I’ve definitely had the misshapen flowers.

Joy Jackson
Joy Jackson (@guest_9843)
1 year ago

I have just learned that my large native lantana has this disease. It was totally new to me and I’ve been gardening for over 45 years. Time to dig it out.

William
William (@guest_12296)
4 months ago

Hi
I’ve noticed my young cosmos plants have started to turn yellow. Not all of them but 3 or 4. Its been really wet virtually all of May so far. Could this be the reason? Or have they got aster yellows some how. Please help

1621413295942152649921642536861.jpg
20210519_093545.jpg
20210519_093537.jpg
Nan Schiller
Nan Schiller (@rellihcsnan)
Admin
Member
Reply to  William
3 months ago

Hello William –
I would hesitate to diagnose aster yellows at this point. There is no indication of leafhopper activity in the form of disfigured foliage.
Wet weather can cause oversaturation, which in turn causes the roots to become waterlogged, and foliage to turn yellow.
We are at the mercy of the weather, however, if you find that the garden is not draining well, you can address this by mixing some sand into the soil, and raising the plants up onto soil mounds.

Emily Ferry
Emily Ferry (@guest_12972)
2 months ago

I have something wrong with hydrangea, black eyed Susan and phlox. Aster yellows??

8C0D8703-CD3C-4C9D-8A99-43EF8E3F9234.jpeg
883DF436-4F75-41CD-A436-7C30A25D167C.jpeg
1E5F303B-285A-4C77-9A91-DD39AEA2B0D0.jpeg
Willett Cynthia
Willett Cynthia (@guest_13905)
1 month ago

I have 9 different varieties of echinacea in my large perennial flower garden and i wonder if you can tell me what might be wrong with them. I live in zone 9b and we have had temperatures in the high 90s for nearly two months now. The first and largest flowering show of my cone flowers were spectacular but after that the very smaller side branched flowers began to have only the cones on the flowers but no flower petals. The plant leaves are all healthy – no curling in or turning brown or yellow and no deformed leaves whatsoever.… Read more »

Clare Groom
Clare Groom (@clareg)
Admin
Member
Reply to  Willett Cynthia
1 month ago

Please could you upload a picture so we can take a look? Thanks!

Emily
Emily (@guest_14282)
1 month ago

I just pulled the coneflowers in my garden that had aster yellows. Now I’m looking to the rest of my plants that may have it. My wild bergamot is doing something strange. It LOOKS exactly like lemon balm, but I know it’s not. But it’s growing it’s flowers in “tiers”, sometimes 5-6 of them! The flowers and leaves look paler and thinner than I would have expected bergamot to be. I’ve emailed the seed producer (Prairie Moon Nursery) for their input. I don’t want to pull what I don’t have to! (My asters are also look stunted and deformed…photo of… Read more »

monardas.jpg
asters.jpg
Nan Schiller
Nan Schiller (@nanschiller)
Noble Member
Reply to  Emily
1 month ago

Hi Emily –
The photos show symptoms like those of aster yellows, however, the eriophyid mite can cause similar ones. We recommend taking ample photos, removing and discarding affected plant material in a sealed trash bag, and contacting your local agricultural extension for a firm diagnosis.
Also, sanitize all pruning equipment and gloves after use.