Native aster species like New England and New York burst into masses of tiny blossoms from mid-summer to first frost.
And while they spread by vigorous root systems and self-sowing, you can increase your aster’s garden footprint to an even greater degree by collecting seed and sowing it wherever you like.
In this article, you will learn the signs of seed readiness and methods for harvest and storage, plus an overview on understanding the differences between propagating native and non-native varieties.
How to Save Aster Seeds
Why Native Species?
The first rule of seed saving is that only true species produce true to seed.
Let me explain. This simply means that if a plant has been manipulated in any way, cross-bred with another, for example, its seeds might not produce “true” replicas of the parent plant.
Hybrids are cultivated varieties created by crossing two or more different plants. Their seeds may produce the characteristics of either plant – or may not be viable at all – but they won’t replicate the hybrid’s characteristics.
So, if you’ve got native plants, you can be certain of the characteristics you’ll get with the seeds you gather. Otherwise, there might be surprises.
Cultivated varieties are propagated by dividing or cutting.
Dividing is slicing straight down through the roots, removing the separated section, and establishing a new plant. You can read more about it here.
A cutting is made by snipping off new growth, dipping it in rooting hormone, then placing it in a container of potting medium. Eventually, it will form roots of its own.
How do you know if your plants are native or cultivated?
Generally speaking, native varieties are more “weedy.” They tend to get quite tall, have branching clusters of small flowers, and spread easily. If your plants are well-behaved, chances are they’re hybrids!
The Time Is Right
Knowing when to harvest is easy. You’ll see them starting to dry out as the first frost date approaches. After each flower blooms, its petals dry, fade, and drift away. When the once-golden center disk turns brown, the seed head has formed, and you can begin.
After a while, the head starts to disintegrate, resembling fluffy tufts of cotton. The fibrous wisps help the seeds to take flight on the first breeze, to self sow wherever they land.
Ways to Collect
There are three preferred methods for aster seed collecting:
- Stalk Harvesting
- Flower Head Snipping
- Seed Head Crumbling
I recommend wearing gloves, because no one knows if they’re allergic to a plant until a tell-tale rash appears. It’s always best to err on the side of caution.
The first method is to cut entire stalks bearing clusters of blossoms. This is an excellent choice for when frost is predicted and you don’t want your plants to turn to mush before you have a chance to harvest.
It’s also beneficial when not all flower heads have gone to seed, because the fresh ones continue to dry on the harvested stalks.
Some folks with large expanses of flowers like to wait until the entire garden looks dried up, and the asters are all cottony. The advantage of this is “one fell swoop” gathering.
The disadvantages are the possibility of missing quite a few that have already sailed away, and waiting too long and potentially losing all of them to frost.
Flower Head Snipping
The second is to collect individual flower heads by holding a paper grocery bag beneath a plant with one hand, and snipping off individual dry flower heads with the other.
Gardeners with smaller plots often pluck the dried heads as they appear. The upside is that self sowing is kept to a minimum, but this requires an exercise in vigilance many would likely find tedious.
This can be a periodic task, in which you remove dry heads as they appear, or an end-of-season event, in which you collect both dry and fresh heads in anticipation of a frost.
By leaving the stalks intact, your garden will still have some winter interest and places for wildlife to shelter.
Seed Head Crumbling
The third method is my favorite. I don’t mind some self seeding, so I wait until I see quite a few brown heads, harvest what I want, and let the rest go.
I take a paper grocery bag, hold it under a plant, and rub the dry heads between my thumb and fingers until they loosen and fall in. You can do this periodically, leaving fresh blooms alone, or at season’s end.
Once gathered, it’s time to prepare them for storage.
First of all discard any heads that are damp or moldy.
The following steps will help to ensure that your harvested seed will be fresh next season, and ready for planting:
- Debris Removal
- Airtight Storage
Flower heads that have gone to seed may look brown and dry on the outside, but might still be moist with life on the inside. To make sure they are completely dry before storage, you’ll need to find a cool, dry location with good air circulation, where they will be undisturbed for one week.
Let’s return to our three collection methods and see how to proceed:
For harvested stalks, simply bind them together with twine, like bouquets, and suspend them upside-down from nails, hooks, etc.. Place newspaper or a clean cloth below to catch loose seed.
You can also bind a paper bag around the stalks to catch them, however, this inhibits air circulation, and may increase the drying time.
For snipped flower heads and crumbled heads, lay out newspaper and spread the contents of your bag(s) over it in a single layer, so all parts receive maximum contact with cool, dry air.
After a week, the heads should be dry and ready for the next step. They’ll probably have the cottony fluff we mentioned still attached, as well as pieces of dry stem and leaf. In other words, it’s a hot mess.
If you find the pieces have not all dried, either allow more time, or discard any material that is still soft, and/or moist.
If you did stalk harvesting, here’s what to do now:
1. Take down each stalk “bouquet,” hold it over the newspaper, and rub the seed heads between your thumb and fingers to release the seeds.
2. Discard the stalks.
3. Crumble the fallen seed and remove as much debris (aka “chaff”) as possible, gently blowing across the newspaper to lift off the lightest fluff.
For snipped flower heads and crumbled heads:
1. Rub the seed heads between your thumbs and fingers, removing as much debris as possible as you go along.
2. Gently blow across the paper to remove remaining fluff.
Once you have removed the excess debris, it’s time to put the seeds away for next season.
What’s the best way to store them?
In airtight containers in a cool, dry location, like a shed or basement. Beware of recommendations to store them in a refrigerator, as it might be too moist.
There are a variety of options, including:
- Glass jars
- Metal tins
- Zippered plastic bags
Let’s evaluate each.
My experience with envelopes has taught me that they are great for indoor storage, where the mice can’t get them. I like that they are opaque, easy to label, and slim to store.
However, even when I used sticky tape instead of sealing them shut, they were hard to open and close as needed. If you like to use just a few at a time in a smaller garden rather than planting the whole lot at once, this might not be the best option for you.
On the other hand, envelopes make a fantastic container for those who wish to give their saved seed as gifts to friends and neighbors.
I’ve always liked to use old baby food jars for storing small seeds. I can identify the contents by marking the lid, see at a glance how many I have, and open and close them as often as needed. They are impervious to insects and rodents, and are inexpensive.
However, as they are clear, I have to keep them inside a cabinet in my shed, instead of on the potting bench near the window. In addition, if I drop one – yikes! Breakable options certainly aren’t for everyone.
If you’re a fan of fancy teas, empty tins may be the perfect choice. They’re opaque, easily labeled with a marker, and seal tightly.
All that and cost effective too? What’s not to love?
Zippered Plastic Bags
I’m a fan of zip bags. I wash mine out and reuse them over and over for household storage. They come in sizes ranging from minute to ginormous, so there’s always one that’s just perfect.
The tight seal and ability to squeeze out excess air for compact storage make these a useful option.
But, the clear quality of the plastic makes it necessary to store in a dark place. Also, the bags are slippery, and unless you like a challenge, they can be hard to manage when you’re wearing garden gloves.
Plan to use harvested seeds the following growing season for best results. And if you’ve got way more than you need but just hate to see them go to waste, package them attractively for hostess gifts or party favors for your gardening friends.
Irresistible Asters for All
Perennial native asters are dynamic plants that readily naturalize. By collecting the seeds that would otherwise disperse, you can grow them wherever you choose.
Save seeds to sow along walls and fences for late season swaths of color, height, and texture.
And if you have gorgeous asters that aren’t native, no worries. Remember, you can propagate them by division or cutting instead.
Asters are so easy to grow, if you don’t already have some, it’s time to add them to this year’s garden planner. And who knows, aster propagation via saving your own seed may become a lifelong hobby you never even imagined!
Have you had success harvesting and saving your own seeds for planting in the spring? Share your stories and let us know if you have any questions in the comments below – we love hearing from you!
If you found this article useful, you might enjoy reading more about growing these lovely flowers including:
- 11 of the Best Pink Aster Varieties
- 21 Tips for Managing Perennial Asters in the Garden
- New England Aster, Sensational Summer Through Fall
- 11 of the Best Blue Asters to Add to the Garden
Ask the Experts, LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. See our TOS for more details. Uncredited photos: Shutterstock.
About Nan Schiller
Nan Schiller is a writer with deep roots in the soil of southeastern Pennsylvania. Her background includes landscape and floral design, a BS in business from Villanova University, and a Certificate of Merit in floral design from Longwood Gardens. An advocate of organic gardening with native plants, she’s always got dirt under her nails and freckles on her nose. With wit and hopefully some wisdom, she shares what she’s learned and is always ready to dig into a new project!